Why Did My Chickens Stop Laying? How to Use an Egg Log to Find Out

EggTally

It’s a cold morning in November. In September you were collecting five eggs a day from six hens. This week the nest box has been empty three days out of four, and you’re starting to wonder whether something is wrong with your flock, or whether this is just what hens do in winter.

Most drops in laying have ordinary causes, such as shorter days, molting or a broody hen. A few are a sign that something needs attention. The good news is that a plain daily egg log, kept in a notebook, a spreadsheet or an app, can narrow it down. It shows you whether the whole flock slowed or just one hen, and whether it happened slowly or overnight.

This guide is written by the developer of EggTally, an iPhone egg counter for backyard chickens: tap + for each egg and a month calendar fills up day by day (app page · view on the App Store).


First, check that they really stopped

Before looking for a cause, make sure the eggs aren’t just somewhere else.

  • Look for hidden nests in bushes, corners and under the coop. Hens that free-range often find their own spots
  • Check for cracked or broken eggs, or shell bits in the nest box
  • Make sure everyone who collects eggs writes them down. A day that wasn’t logged looks the same as a day with no eggs

That last point is why a good log records zero-egg days on purpose. Write “0” on days with no eggs, and leave the cell blank only when nobody checked.

Common reasons hens stop laying, and what the log shows

Reason What the log tends to show What to note alongside
Shorter days The whole flock slows gradually through fall and winter Date, and whether you use any added light
Molt Fewer eggs, usually in fall, while the hen loses and regrows feathers Which hen, and when the feather loss started
Broody hen One hen stops while the others keep laying Which hen is sitting tight in the nest
Age Each year is a little lower than the year before Each hen’s hatch date
Stress A sudden drop right after a change The event: a move, a predator, new birds, a heat wave
A health problem Any drop, sometimes with other signs Anything unusual you see, and when

What extension specialists say about each one:

  • Day length: Oregon State notes that preventing losses from changes in natural day length “requires artificial lighting,” and that a 14- to 16-hour day is typical for laying flocks[1]. Whether to add light in winter is your choice. A log simply shows you how big the winter dip is for your flock
  • Molt: it “usually occurs in the fall”[1]
  • Broodiness: “When a hen becomes broody, hormonal changes result in the cessation of lay”[1]. To reduce broodiness, the same guide suggests collecting eggs daily “from nests and hiding places”[1]
  • Age: “Normally, chickens produce well until they are 2 to 3 years old, and then egg production declines”[1]
  • Stress: even stress “so minimal as to go unnoticed” can stop a hen from laying[1]
  • Health: “In many cases, a drop in egg production is the first sign of trouble”[1]

What to write down every day

You don’t need much. These columns are enough to answer the questions in the next section.

Column Example Why
Date Nov 14 The base of every comparison
Eggs 3 (write 0 on empty days) Tells you how many eggs, and whether anyone checked
Hen (if you know) Pepper 1, Hazel 1, unknown 1 Shows whether one hen or the whole flock slowed
Cracked or not used 1 Keeps your usable count honest
Note First frost; new feeder Lets you match drops to events

Keep a separate short list of your hens with a hatch date and a status (laying, not laying yet, molting, broody, retired). Update the status on the day it changes. That one date is often what tells you, weeks later, why a month was low.

You don’t have to know who laid every egg. Many keepers only know a few hens by egg color or nest habits. Count the rest as “unknown” and the totals still work.

Four questions to ask your log

  1. Is it the whole flock or one hen? One hen points to broodiness, molt or that hen’s age and health. The whole flock points to daylight, season or something in the coop
  2. Was it gradual or sudden? A slow slide over weeks fits daylight and age. A drop from one day to the next fits stress or an event, so check your notes for that week
  3. Is it lower than the same month last year? If last November was also low, the season explains a lot. If last November was fine, look harder
  4. What changed just before? New birds, a move, a predator visit, a feed change, a hot spell. Your note column answers this one

If you see anything that worries you about a hen’s health, don’t wait for the log to explain it. A drop can be the first sign of trouble[1], so ask a veterinarian who sees poultry.

Use a laying rate, not just a total

Totals mislead when your flock changes size. Six hens laying 108 eggs is not the same as nine hens laying 108 eggs.

The classic flock-record measure is hen-day production: total eggs for a period divided by the average number of birds in the flock on each day of that period[2]. As a simple formula:

laying rate = eggs ÷ (hens × days)

Example: 6 hens for 30 days is 180 hen-days. If they laid 108 eggs, the laying rate is 108 ÷ 180 = 60%.

Decide which birds you count and stick with it. Young hens that haven’t started laying and retired hens drag the rate down without telling you anything new, so many keepers leave them out. What matters is that this month and last year are counted the same way.

A worked example

Here’s a made-up flock of six hens, comparing three months with the same months last year. Hen-days are 180 for September and November (30 days) and 186 for October (31 days).

Month Eggs Laying rate Last year Notes
September 135 75% 72% Normal
October 98 53% 61% Hazel and Pepper molting from Oct 10
November 61 34% 45% Days short; Juniper broody from Nov 3

Reading it with the four questions:

  • The whole flock slowed through fall, as it did last year, so daylight explains much of it
  • October is lower than last year. The status list shows two hens molting at the same time
  • In November, one hen (Juniper) stopped completely the day she went broody, while the others kept laying a little

Nothing here proves a cause on its own. But the log turns “they stopped laying” into specific facts: which hens, since when, and how it compares with last year. Those are also exactly the details a vet will ask about if you need one.

Common mistakes

  • Leaving empty days blank, so a zero can’t be told apart from a day nobody logged
  • Comparing totals between months with different numbers of hens
  • Forgetting to note when a hen’s status changed, so a low month can’t be explained later
  • Only looking at this month. The same month last year is the most useful comparison
  • Waiting on the log when a hen looks unwell

What each egg costs you, including in slow months, is in How to calculate the cost per egg for backyard chickens. If a broody hen ends up sitting on eggs, the dates to plan for are in Chicken egg hatching timeline.

How EggTally keeps this log for you

EggTally’s first screen, Eggs, is the daily log described above.

  • Tap + once for each egg. Know who laid it? Tap her chip instead, or sort it out later by tapping that day in the calendar
  • “No eggs today” marks a zero day, so it can’t be confused with a day you forgot
  • The month calendar shows each day’s count. Tap a day to fix the total, split it between hens, mark cracked or unused eggs, and add a note or photos
  • In Flock, each hen has a status (laying, pullet, molting, broody, sick or injured, retired) and a hatch date. Sort by “Recently laid” to see who hasn’t laid lately, and each hen’s page shows when she last laid
  • Stats shows the laying rate, eggs per day, a hen ranking, month by month against last year, and by season. The laying rate counts hens that are laying, molting, broody, or sick or injured, and leaves out pullets and retired hens
  • Small and medium Home Screen widgets have a + button, so you can count at the coop without opening the app

Health notes in EggTally are a record only. The app doesn’t give health advice.

Every feature is free. The free version holds 60 days with eggs. Zero-egg days, hens, costs, health notes and hatches don’t count toward the limit. EggTally Pro is a one-time purchase that removes the 60-day limit and the watermark on share cards. No account is needed, and what you log stays on your device (app page · view on the App Store).

Summary

  • Rule out hidden nests and unlogged days first. Write 0 on days with no eggs
  • Common reasons for a drop are shorter days, molt, a broody hen, age and stress. A drop can also be the first sign of a health problem
  • Ask your log four questions: whole flock or one hen, gradual or sudden, compared with last year, and what changed just before
  • Compare laying rates (eggs ÷ hen-days), not totals, and count the same hens each time
  • If a hen looks unwell, talk to a veterinarian rather than waiting for the numbers

Sources

  1. James Hermes, “Why did my chickens stop laying?” (PNW 565), Oregon State University Extension (2003, reviewed 2023) https://extension.oregonstate.edu/catalog/pnw-565-why-did-my-chickens-stop-laying
  2. Melvin L. Hamre, “Keeping and Using Flock Records,” University of Minnesota Agricultural Extension Service (1987) https://conservancy.umn.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/2c8507d5-cba0-4e1c-9218-f5d19345ca85/content

(All checked November 18, 2026.)


About the sources for this article This article is based on information from public agencies, official sites and specialist media, reorganized by the editors from a recording and organizing perspective. Figures and statements about specifications or safety were checked against primary sources where possible.


This article organizes information from a recording and organizing perspective. For questions about your birds’ health, please consult a veterinarian. If you notice an error or outdated information, please contact us. Last verified: November 2026

Copied title and URL